The Election of the Patriarch of Armenian Patriarchate of Istanbul: the Possible Candidates and the Turkish Factor
Armenians of Istanbul are still waiting for the election of the Patriarch of Constantinople Patriarchate of the Armenian Apostolic Church. On October 26 the Armenian Patriarchate of Constantinople announced about its decision of declaring the Patriarchal seat of the Armenian Patriarchate of Istanbul as "vacant" and launching the process of electing a new Patriarch.
Since 2008 Patriarch Mesrob Mutafyan is in coma and actually since then he has not been acting as Patriarch. The Turkish government, which controls the selection of the leaders of religious communities, however, does not allow the election of a new patriarch. As a result, Archbishop Aram Ateshyan leads the Patriarchate, which causes dissatisfaction of the Armenian community, as he is selected not by the community but by the state.
Armenian community of Istanbul has repeatedly called on the Turkish authorities to hold elections of patriarch, but has not received permission. Turkish authorities claim that the possibility to hold new elections can be only after the patriarch's death. In February 2015 during the meeting with representatives of the national minorities Turkish Deputy Prime Minister Bulent Arinc said that it was possible to hold elections of Patriarch, if there were report on the health status of the Archbishop Mesrob II Mutafian.
It should be noted, that the decision to dismiss Mutafyan was taken, taking into account the report of the forensic medical commission of 2015, as well as according to church canons, the patriarch absence of seven years is sufficient for the dissolution of the covenant. Therefore, the absence of eight years of the Patriarch confirms the dissolution of the "patriarchal covenant."
Now in case of approval of the decision to dismiss Patriarch Mutafyan by the Turkish government, election of a new patriarch will be held, during which the Armenian community of Istanbul will choose its spiritual leader.
Speaking about possible candidates for the Patriarch of Constantinople, it should be noted, that since there is no official permission, it is still too early to talk about candidates. However circulating names include Ateshyan and Mashalyan, Garegin Archbishop Bekchyan, leader of Germany’s diocese and leader of Gugark Diocese, Bishop Sepuh Chuljyan. Khajak Archbishop Parsamyan and Vigen Archbishop Aykazyan are also among possible candidates. Now it is difficult to say who is the most likely candidate for Patriarch, but definitely Deputy Patriarch Aram Archbishop Ateshyan will hardly succeed, as the Armenian community treats him solely as a puppet of the Turkish authorities.
It should be noted, that earlier in the expectation of elections permission Ateshyan, Bekchyan and Chuljyan had already had meetings with the community and at that time Chuljyan was considered the most likely candidate.
The Armenian Patriarchate of Constantinople recognizes the primacy of the Catholicos of All Armenians, in the spiritual and administrative headquarters of the Armenian Church. However, according to Turkish laws the permit of the election of the Patriarch of Istanbul is given by the governor of Istanbul, who in his turn gets it from the Interior Ministry.
It should be noted that the similar situation when Turkish authorities have forbidden to choose the Armenian Patriarch in Turkey happened twice: the first when Kemalists came to power and started Kemalist nationalism and the second in the 1940s - the rise of nationalism and pan-Turkism.
- EU Urges Turkey to Stop Offering Russia Solutions to Circumvent Sanctions Speaking about the EU's engagement with Turkey, an important neighbor, EU partner and candidate country for EU membership, we stress the importance of ensuring that Turkey's foreign policy is aligned with...
- Any Change of Internationally Recognized Borders in Region is Unacceptable – Iranian President to Erdogan "The basis of our policy in the region is that the fates of the countries must be determined by themselves and that their national sovereignty and territorial integrity must be respected" Raisi told Erdogan...
- Azerbaijan, Turkey FMs Discuss Regional Situation During the phone talk, the two FMs exchanged opinions on the current regional situation and the agenda of bilateral cooperation.
- Erdogan, Biden Might Meet in September- Media Turkey plans to buy 40 F-16 fighter jets from the US and upgrade another eighty. US President Joe Biden stated that he expects to receive the approval of the [US] Congress to sell F-16 fighter jets to...
- Azerbaijani FM Informed Turkish FM About the Attack On the Azerbaijani Embassy In London During the telephone conversation, the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkiye expressed concern about the attack of a gang of radical religious groups on the building of the Embassy of the Republic of...
Pope Francis vows to visit both Kiev and Moscow, if he travels
Two soldiers wounded as Azerbaijan violates ceasefire: Artsakh MoD
Azerbaijan hands over bodies of 13 soldiers to Armenia
Arayik Harutyunyan convened a working consultation
5-Day Weather Forecast In Armenia
Armenian Defense Minister chairs consultation
Prime Minister Pashinyan sends congratulatory message to the Prime Minister of Albania
Strong political will needed by Azerbaijan and Armenia to achieve comprehensive settlement: EU
All participants are seeking to achieve peace in the region, the signing of a peace treaty, legal registration of existing borders, unblocking of transport connections: Zas
Ilham Aliyev received U.S. State Department's Senior Advisor for Caucasus Negotiations
Russia, U.S. have ways to manage nuclear risks - RIA cites U.S. diplomat
Armenian President congratulates Albanian counterpart on Independence Day
UK military aid to Ukraine may increase in 2023
Artsakh forces deny shoiting at Azerbaijani positions
Azerbaijani troops open fire at Armenian positions
There are difficult to pass and closed roadways in Armenia
PM Pashinyan, together with his wife, attends the charity concert in support of the soldiers being treated at the Soldier's Home
Stanislav Zas: CSTO proposed several measures to help Armenia
The Ministry of Defence of Azerbaijan has spread disinformation
Attempts to disintegrate CSTO will continue, Kremlin spokesman warns
The Prime Minister leaves for Tunisia on a working visit
Azerbaijan's attempts to abolish the status of Artsakh as a party to the conflict is unacceptable: Artsakh MFA
Putin to attend CSTO summit in Armenia next week, Kremlin confirms
Putin and Erdogan discuss details of creating a gas hub in Turkey: Kremlin
Azerbaijan’s defense ministry spreads another misinformation: MoD Armenia
Nikol Pashinyan and Charles Michel meet in Djerba
Russia bars entry to 200 US citizens: Russian Foreign Ministry
Armenian Security Council Secretary and Indian PM's Advisor discuss security cooperation
Azerbaijan carries out tactical maneuvers
5-Day Weather Forecast in Armenia
Wind: 0 km/h