Lessons and Results of the Catalan Referendum
On October 1, the people in Catalonia once more voiced the will to become independent from Spain, participating in the independence referendum.
Despite all the efforts of Madrid to overturn the referendum, the ban of the Constitutional court, the use of the force by the police, more than half of the Catalan people participated in the referendum and 90 percent of the participants said “Yes” to independence.
The struggle for independence of Catalonia contains several important components.
National: the Catalans are different from the Spanish by their ethnicity and struggle for the preservation of their language and identity, while the policy of Madrid is considered by them as the intention “to make Catalonia more Spanish.” Thus, this struggle, first of all, is a struggle for preservation of identity.
Financial: Catalonia is one of the most economically developed regions of Spain and has the largest tourist flows. The economic calculations show that currently Catalonia invests more in the Spanish budget than receives from it. It became even obvious after the Spanish economic crisis. For example, 9,5%- of the state budget was allocated to Catalonia in 2015 as compared to that of 16% in 2003.
Political: After long negotiations between Madrid and Barcelona, in 2006 an agreement was signed, according to which the Catalan autonomy was considerable widened: Barcelona got comparably considerable financial, administrative freedoms, while the Catalans were recognized as a “nation.” However, in 2010, based on the decision of the constitutional court, some points of the agreement were annulled, which resulted in this wave for independence.
Today’s tough policy employed by Madrid makes the situation even tense. Before the referendum, the results of the polls showed that only 41% of the population is for the independence, while 41% against. However the stance of Madrid and the steps initiated on the eve of the referendum (attempt to prevent the realization of the referendum, the police forces sent for Madrid, the arrests of the referendum organizers and so on) changed the public mood. Besides, the pro-Spanish political forces, that gained 40% votes in the previous parliamentary elections, boycotted the referendum, thus increasing the chances of the “Yes” vote. Consequently, more than half of the population, eligible to vote, participated in the referendum and 90% of them voted for independence.
The police actions on the eve and during it cannot pass without consequences: there are more than 700 wounded people among the referendum participants. The EU will be forced to react and criticize such a demonstration of violence against the wish of the people to express their will in a democratic way. It does not mean that the EU will support the independence of Catalonia. Trying to avoid the domino effect and additional problems with Madrid, Brussels aims at not interfering in the issue. Moreover, the EU will indirectly try to prevent the dissemination of separatism (according to the EU policy, the EU member separatist units also quit the EU). However, not criticizing the demonstration of violence will mean the denial of own principles and values.
Now the parliament of Catalonia should decide on declaring the independence. However, both sides, despite the decisive rhetoric and mutual accusations, consider the possibility of negotiation. Prime Minister of Spain, Mariano Rajoy, declared that they “leave a door open” and are ready to negotiate, however only in the framework of the law. President of Catalonia, Carles Puigdemont, in his turn declared that the “joint declaration on the independence is not on the table” and he is ready to negotiate. Logically, the next step will be negotiations, but the violence demonstrated by Madrid and tension in the public moods, as a result of it, raised the bar for Catalan concession.
One can also draw certain concussions for other issues relating to the self-determination.
The demonstration of violence by Madrid and the change of the public moods, as a result of it, once more proved that such problems should be resolved exclusively in a peaceful way, through dialogue.
Besides, the attention of the international community was once more drawn to the issue of self-determination. The example of Catalonia shows that the issue of self-determination and preservation of identity is always actual and important. If in the democratic EU member state Spain the issue of t independence for the preservation of identity is raised. It is more than natural that such an issue is to the point and actual in developing countries, especially in cases, when the self-determination is a security issue.
Kofi Annan, Former UN Secretary General, Dies
Yerevan City Council Early Elections to be Held on September 23
Artsakh Republic President Met with the General Staff of the Republic of Armenia Armed Forces
Trump: US Will Pay Nothing for Pastor
Turkey Arrests Another German Citizen
Angela Merkel to Visit Armenia Next Week
Guinea Citizen Ilegally Crossed Armenia-Turkey Border
"Armenian Velvet Revolution" Book Released
Turkey's Biggest Mobile Phone Importing Companies Cancel their Phone Orders
Government Creates Favorable Conditions for Doing Business and Making Profits – PM Pashinyan
Nikol Pashinyan: "Over the past 100 days, we have solved the key problem: we have ensured the country’s normal functioning and economic development"
Armenian PM, Russia President Talk on Phone
Turkey Intends to Establish Close Ties with EU
Trump Says His Tariffs will Rescue US Industry
Main Side of the Conflict Cannot be Withdrawn or Put Aside from Negotiation Table – Artsakh Parliament Speaker
Dollar Drops in Armenia
At Least 25 Killed in Suicide Blast in Kabul
Turkish Court Releases Local Chair of Amnesty International
Information of the Artsakh Republic State Commission on Prisoners of War, Hostages and Missing Persons
President Sahakyan Visited the Town of Martouni
New Wave of Hysteria Raised in Azerbaijan Due to the Possible Visit of Russian Singer with Armenian Surname
Artsakh Republic President Sahakyan, Minister Minasyan Discuss Economic Cooperation Between Artsakh and Armenia
Robert Kocharyan Released: Court of Appeals Approves Attorneys’ Appeal
Israel: All the Citizens are Equal, but Jews are More Than Equal
Armenia PM: Every Penny Stolen from People Will be Returned
"We are Gure to Gain a Victory in our Common Mission" – Nikol Pashinyan Attends Event Dedicated to Armenian General Athletic Union Centenary
Greens Call for New Zealand's Parliament to Recognise Armenian Genocide
Foreign Minister of South Ossetia Congratulated on the 25th Anniversary of the Establishment of the MFA of the Republic of Artsakh
Artsakh MFA Received Congratulatory Message from Abkhazia MFA on the 25th Anniversary of the Establishment
Foreign Minister of Artsakh Received Coordinator of the "Congress of Refugees from the Azerbaijani SSR" NGO
Wind: 22.53 km/h