The Ghost of “Lavrov’s Plan”

The sides have problems of understanding each other’s perceptions and commenting on the perception of the actual process.

Will Artsakh Take Part in Implementing the Agreements Reached in the Humanitarian Field?

As a result of the meeting there are agreements reached at least in three aspects – imprisoned people’s relatives’ visits, mutual visits of mass media representatives and no firing during agricultural work.

Pashinyan Emphasized Karabakh Conflict Settlement Process at PACE

On April 11 prime minister Pashinyan made a statement at the PACE session and answered question of the MPs. Alongside the revolution in Armenia, democratic improvements, relationships with neighbor countries and others Pashinyan spoke about the Karabakh conflict settlement process.

EU Agrees to Brexit Extension Once Again

Leaders of the countries remaining in the European Union have agreed to extend Brexit until October 31.

Russia Again Active in the Karabakh Talks Process

Following the revolution in Armenia this will be the first Russian mediated meeting aside from introducing Pashinyan and Aliyev to each other in Moscow.

Which Country is to Follow the Footsteps of Germany to Ratify Armenia-EU Agreement?

Germany became the 11th EU member state to ratify the Armenia-EU agreement. Sweden is expected to be the next in the near future.

Confidence Building Against No Fulfillment of Obligation

These days the 3rd year of the April war is commemorated. And now more than ever, it is pressing to talk about the mechanisms intended to prevent the possible resumption of hostilities and ceasefire violations.

Lessons Learnt From April War

It has been three years since the April war, but the days with their horrible consequences have not faded away which makes it difficult to analyze the issue without emotions.

Pashinyan-Aliyev Meeting: Results and Talks Development Prospects

Positive assessment, lack of tangible results, can be a brief description of March 29 Vienna meeting between Nikol Pashinyan and Ilham Aliyev.

OSCE MG Co-Chairs’ Statement Signals a Range of Shortfalls

On March 9 the OSCE MG co-chairs issued a statement prior to Aliyev-Pashinyan upcoming meeting. Before we come to the content of the statement one thing should be pointed out.

Pashinyan’s Brussels Visit: Positive Tendencies, No Tangible Results

OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs Endeavoring to Set Talks on Course: Statement That Came Ten Days Later

It turns out that the mediators come to learn the details of a January 22 meeting only a month later.

Prospects for Development of EU-Armenia Relations Are Being Noted

European Commissioner for European Neighborhood Policy and Enlargement Negotiations Johannes Hahn visited Armenia in the beginning of the week.

EU-Armenia Relations in 2018: Uncertainty and Expectations

In 2018 the relations between Armenia and the European Union entered into an important phase: in November 2017, the Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement was signed between Armenia and EU.

2018 Was Quite Active in Terms of Contacts on the Karabakh Conflict

In total, during this year, the negotiation process can be divided into two stages: before the revolution in Armenia and after the revolution.

Armenia's Foreign Policy Developments in 2018 (summary)

2018 was a unique year for Armenia in terms of domestic political developments that directly and indirectly had its influence both on the foreign policy of the country and on the intensification of relations with different countries.

US-Russian Competition in South Caucasus is Getting Much Stronger

Let's note that this was quite a unique visit. The last time the US President's Security Advisor visited Armenia in 1997 and was the first time in Azerbaijan.

Transfer of the CSTO PA Session from Yerevan to Moscow is a Reflection of the Current Moods

The decision to postpone the venue of the session, of course, does not mean deterioration of Armenia’s relations with other CSTO member states. However, it can be said that what has happened is a consequence and a continuation of not very smooth developments in relations between Armenia and the CSTO in recent times.

US Ambassador's Statement May Be Perceived as a Special Signal in Baku

The essence of the Artsakh issue is the struggle for the realization of the Artsakh people's right to self-determination. Therefore, peace will be possible only when Azerbaijan recognizes that right.

There is a Need to Specify the Subject of the Karabakh Negotiations

Based on the results of approximately three-hour talks, first in an expanded format, then in a tete-a-tete format, it is noted only that there was an exchange of views on the settlement of the Karabakh conflict and the need to establish a stable peace in the region, and also the parties expressed readiness to continue the dialogue.

Armenia Has to Answer Lavrov As An Equal Partner

The fight against corruption and the disclosure of crimes, the implementation of fair trial and the preservation of the law are the main goals of any democratic country and the natural demand of the Armenian public.

Does Pashinyan Have Any Concern Connected With Moscow?

Nikol Pashinyan's reference is also about the threat of war resumption. He noted that there is always danger of war and the Armenian people should always be ready for it.

What Does Armenian Prime Minister Expect from EU?

It is quite natural that the rapid pace and success of democratic processes in Armenia are awarded a positive assessment from the EU, and this assessment must be materialized. Let's try to clarify what practical steps can be expected from the EU at this stage.

Moscow Should Comment on the Russian Officials' Visit to Leletepe

It is more than obvious what goals Azerbaijan pursued by organizing this action: to legitimize the return of territories by military means, while using the representatives of the country co-chairing the OSCE Minsk Group and Armenia's strategic ally, to show how well Azerbaijan "takes care" of these territories and use all this in information war against Armenia and Artsakh.

Azerbaijan, in Fact, Refuses Any Negotiation, Threatening by War

Azerbaijani side acknowledged that they are ready to begin military operations at the first convenient moment. And this, in fact, is a refusal of a political settlement through negotiations.

Three Tasks of the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs Visit to Armenia

Despite the statements of the new authorities on the continuity of Armenia's policy on the Karabakh issue, there are some new accents. And in this case, the co-chairs would like to understand how much these new accents fit into the existing logic of the negotiations and what developments they can lead to.

Rapid Implementation of Armenia-EU Agreement Can Open Wide Opporunities

It is noteworthy that even partial, but quick implementation of the agreement will give an additional impetus to the reforms being implemented in Armenia with the EU support, as well as will deepen Armenia-EU cooperation in a number of spheres. As a result, the agreement will have a direct impact on the lives of Armenian citizens.

Armenia Stays Loyal to Its Two-Vector Integration Policy

Reactions to Nikol Pashinyan's election as prime minister also testified the consistent work that had been carried out with both Russia and the West.

Ratification of Armenia-EU Agreement Is Important First of All for Armenian Citizens

If we refer to the meaning of ratification of the agreement on behalf of Armenia, then two components can be distinguished: political and practical.

Last Visit of Serzh Sargsyan's Presidency: Values Instead of Contradictions

Armenia, the Armenian people and the Armenian Apostolic Church had and have an important role in the Christian world. Armenia is the boundary of Christianity and the European civilization based on Christian values, it is one of the sources of Christian culture and values.

Statement of Artsakh President Has Not Only Political, but Humanitarian Importance

This statement of Artsakh President, according to which Azerbaijani refugees can return any time, in case they recognize the Republic of Artsakh and its jurisdiction, is very important and symbolic. It has not only political, but also humanitarian importance.

EaP Results Become More Visible to the Citizens

It is important to note that if initially the EU was guided by a single mechanism for building cooperation with all six EaP countries, then soon they realized that this is inefficient.

What Will We Have in the Observers' Reports after Azerbaijani Elections?

In April elections, the opposition of Azerbaijan will participate almost spontaneously, and observers will not have legal grounds for proving even the most obvious restrictions.

Baku's Response Confirmed the Rightness of the RA President's Words

Moreover, in an answer to the RA President's calls to abandon the ambitious demands, Baku declared that "the Armenian and Azerbaijani communities of Nagorno-Karabakh can enjoy self-determination within Azerbaijan." It also reaffirmed its demands for withdrawing Armenian troops from Artsakh as the first step. This is nothing more than an ambitious demand and destructiveness.

The Priority in the Negotiations Is the Implementation of Agreements Reached in Vienna, St. Petersburg and Geneva

the Ministers have in general agreed on the extension of the Office of the Personal Representative of the OSCE Chairman-in-Office presented by the Co-Chairs. And this means that the mediators endeavor to achieve tangible results in at least one of the agreements reached in Vienna and St. Petersburg

Why is the Quick Ratification of the Agreement between Armenia and the EU Important?

In order for the agreement to enter into force and all sides to fulfill their obligations, the agreement must be ratified both by the parliaments of 28 EU member states and the European Parliament.

Karabakh Conflict Settlement Process in 2017

Summing up, we can state that 2017, in general, passed in a rather tense atmosphere, which was on one hand conditioned by Azerbaijani stance to violate the agreements aimed at strengthening ceasefire regime, on the other hand by the regular increase of tension on the border at the beginning of the year.

Armenia's Integration Processes in 2017

This year, by signing the Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement with the EU, Armenia has finally implemented its "both and" policy.

Armenia’s Agreement with the European Union Does Not Impose Threat for Russia

Not only Armenia but also EAEU partner countries will do their best to take maximum advantage of this opportunity.

Kiev and Moscow Can Start a Dialogue on Humanitarian Issues for Now

Besides, this can become a precedent for the future cooperation of Kiev and Moscow as the attempt is made to separate a number political disagreements from humanitarian issues. This can later be also used for other conflicts.

The Final Declaration of the EaP Summit and Reference to Armenia (Analysis)

Summarizing, it can be mentioned that in some terms very general and compromising formulations were chosen in the Brussels Declaration. As for Armenia, in general, the document reflects a positive assessment of the great work done, overcoming the many uncertainties and the desire of both the EU and Armenia to move forward.

Moldova-Armenia Cooperation Builds New Bridges between the EAEU and EU

Thus, the cooperation with Moldova can have its contribution to strengthening the position and role of Armenia in the EAEU. In parallel, it will build bridges between the European and Eurasian unions.

Sargsyan Answered to Aliyev: Karabakh Should Be Outside Azerbaijan

After the talks, Sargsyan responded to Aliyev, stressing that the only solution for us is that Karabakh be outside Azerbaijan and no Armenian leader will ever adopt another decision. In this way Sargsyan made it clear that Armenia's constructiveness and restraint behavior in the negotiation process should not be misinterpreted by Aliyev clan.

Barcelona-Madrid: Time to Negotiate

From the very start of this process it was predictable that the final aim of Catalonia is not that much independence, but getting higher degree of autonomy. In this regard the passions were more aggravated by the tough reaction of the official Madrid on holding a referendum and the use of violence.

Lessons and Results of the Catalan Referendum

The struggle for independence of Catalonia contains several important components.

The Status of Artsakh Will Not Be Lower Than Today

In his speech, the President stated that the Karabakh issue is, first and foremost, a human rights issue and should be solved on the basis of respect for the fundamental human rights, that is, the realization of the right to self-determination and the security of the Artsakh people, as all other problems are derivative and secondary.

The Causes of Aliyev's "Humanity"

At the same time, taking into consideration the complicated relations between Turkey and the EU and the slightest possibility of getting support from Ankara, in the current situation, Baku has to "make concessions" not to create new problems for itself and not to exacerbate international pressure.

US Tries to Demonstrate Activity as a Minsk Group Co-Chair

We can state that currently the mediators take steps to restart the negotiation process and its basis, while the US, in its turn makes active efforts.

The Issue of Genocide Should Not Be Manipulated By Israel

The manipulation of the issue of the Armenian Genocide, as a tool of political pressure or black-mail against Turkey is unacceptable, especially by Israel.

The State-Building Processes in Artsakh Are Very Important

The people of Artsakh organizes its life according to the threats and needs, that it faces, at the same time being condemned to the democratic values. This is the most important factor, on one side for the people of Artsakh, on the other side for preventing and steps back in conflict settlement process.

The Co-Chairs of the OSCE MG Should Review Their Approaches

In this context, it would be logical, that in response to the attampts of Azerbaijan to avoid Vienna and St.Petersburg agreements, the Co-Chairs of the OSCE MG raised an issue of widening the contacts with Artsakh, for example, by establishing the Co-Chairs’ office in Stepanakert.

The Scandal around Agramount Limits the Opportunities of Azerbaijani Lobby

This process is important not only in the context of PACE. Logically, this must be a signal for European MPs in different international organisations, who will avoid deals with Azerbaijan not to put their reputation under risk.

The OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs’ Targeted Statements are Not Sufficient

Another issue is that the statement does not mention the loss of life recorded during their visit, and most importantly, the wording of the criticism is mild, with no clear-cut measures.

EU Tries To Sober Turkey

And now the government of Turkey announces, that it can easily give up its plans for becoming an EU member state. The prosecutions in that country, pressure on journalists, expansion of Erdogan's powers and strengthening of Islamic values show that Turkey is really going away from the European values, at the same time issuing ultimatums to Brussels.

May Will Have to Make Concessions

It is quite interesting that the labor party has considerably improved its position – a party, which did not use the motto "not to Brexit", but they are more prone to soft Brexit.

Stepanakert-Shushi Flights Have Frightened Baku

Meanwhile, the Azerbaijani side represents this as a violation of Azerbaijan's airspace, continuing the scandal raised around using the airport in Stepanakert.

Do Only Armenian Sides Need Peace?

Peace cannot be presented as a concession to Artsakh and Armenia, as it is equally important for all countries of the region and first of all for all people.

A New Trilateral Agreement Is Needed to Strengthen the Ceasefire

The most appropriate thing to do in this situation will be to sign a new trilateral agreement of non-use of force and threat of force on the basis of 1994 Agreement.

The Issue of Northern Ireland Can Be Used Against the United Kingdom

In fact, today Northern Ireland does not have a clear desire to leave the United Kingdom and unite with the Republic of Ireland, but rather wants to get guarantees that in case of such a desire it can immediately be included in the European Union, bypassing the long pre-membership process.

The OSCE Should Review Its Principles

Another question is whether by succeeding in a formal way, Azerbaijan will de-facto succeed. Today the OSCE leadership, the Presidency discuss issues of maintaining all aspects of cooperation on security in the South Caucasus and on finding alternative ways of engagement.

Is the Prime Minister of the UK Quiting the Idea of Brexit?

The British people has already answered this question during last elections and referendum, and today May has the necessary number of supporters in the parliament to put forward the process of Brexit. In this context the decision of May seems quite strange.

In the Parliamentary Elections of the RA the "And-And" Policy Won

It can be noted that two of the four political forces represented in the parliament clearly emphasize the importance of developing cooperation with both the Eurasian Union and the European Union. One of the other two forces also supports the "and-and" policy, since at the moment it is the best one in terms of the interests of Armenia.

Moldova Follows Armenia's Example: EAEU-Moldova Memorandum Signed

Moldova is the first country, that has already signed the Association Agreement and DCFTA and at the same time wishes to cooperate with the EAEU. In fact, Chisinau followed the example of Armenia – the policy of "and-and".

The Pre-Signing of the RA-EU New Framework Agreement Is a Result of Effective Dialogue

By pre-signing and later by signing the Agreement, Armenia fixed its commitment to the European values, to its will for carrying out reforms in the country.

France Attaches Importance to Armenia's EAEU Membership

On the other hand, the President of Armenia, in turn, confirmed Armenia's readiness to contribute to the cooperation between the EAEU and the EU.

"And-And" Policy of Armenia Is Effectively Being Carried Out

EU leaders, including Donald Tusk, stressed in their statements that Armenia is an important partner for the EU, and they are ready to promote the deepening of the reform.

The Main Message of the RA President During His Visit to Brussels Was the Effective Implementation of "And-And" Policy by Armenia: Anna Karapetyan

According to the expert, the main message of the Armenian President's visit to Brussels was the effective application of the "and-and" policy. "European leaders' statements suggest that the EU gives great importance to the cooperation with Armenia and intends to develop effective relations with Armenia."

EU-Armenia New Agreement Is a New Cornerstone for Our Relations

In particular, reference was made to Azerbaijan's recent statements on the status quo and it was specified that there is only one way to change the status quo, it is the recognition of self-determination of Artsakh people.

The Case of Lapshin Can Force Armenia Recognize NKR Independence

It’s not excluded, that if this policy of Azerbaijan continues, one day Baku can decide “to punish” also Armenia and demand to arrest and send to Baku all Armenians, who have visited NKR. What will then happen?

The Proper Quality of Holding Parliamentary Elections Will Further Promote RA-EU Relations

Constitutional reforms, as well as the new Electoral Code agreed and adopted with the dialogue of the opposition and the civil society is a "step forward" in the democratization process.

A New Geopolitical Axis is Developing

Thus it turns out that now all those countries are getting united that have strained relations with Brussels, and at the same time, those countries that play an important role for the EU in economic and political spheres and in security matters.

"Tough Brexit": What Will Britain Gain and Lose?

Given the EU's position on the Scottish independence referendum, it can be assumed that the Brussels will avoid to directly supporting Edinburg. However, it is not excluded that Scotland will play its role in "punishing" Britain.

Who Hinders the Reunification of Cyprus?

At the same time on certain issues Turkey is not ready to compromise and insists on the need of its military presence (even with small number) on the island, which makes difficulties in reaching an agreement. This, most probably, at the current stage of the negotiations is the most difficult issue, over which Greece is not ready to compromise.

Co-Chairs In Particular Stressed the Importance of Finalizing OSCE Investigative Mechanism

The main drawbacks of the statement are perhaps again the non-addressed calls, the principle of equalization of the Co-Chairs.

The EU-RA Relations in 2016

In parallel to the political component, the negotiations on the economic component of the new framework agreement are also going on.

Which Document Is on the Negotiation Table of Karabakh Conflict Settlement?

The so called "Lavrov plan" was also widely discussed, which allegedly assumes concession of 5 regions to Azerbaijan, instead having open communication; a plan, which allegedly does not have any clear implication on Karabakh’s status.

Azerbaijan Again Failed to "Get Rid" of the Investigative Mechanisms

In parallel, in the framework of this year’s Ministerial summit the OSCE Secretary General, Lamberto Zanier declared that the OSCE works in developing investigative mechanisms of the incidents on Karabakh conflict zone.

The Success of the EU-Armenia Negotiations is Important for All Parties

Armenia has always declared that it does not accept the principle that the two integration vectors contradict each other and it will seek to move with "and…and" principle.

Moldova is also Retreating from Extreme Pro-Western Direction?

Regardless of the fact that the new president considers himself a pro-Russian politician, and was in favor of the normalization of Russian-Moldovan relations, it is unlikely that Moldova refuses the European integration vector.

Igor Popov Denied Aliyev’s Words

It is absolutely meaningless to comment the other words of the president of Azerbaijan, who says Armenia is to be blamed for the prolongation of conflict settlement. It is obvious, who is destructive and who is perceived or not perceived by the international community and the mediators.

Aliyev Confessed that He is Being Forced to Recognize the Independence of NKR

The negotiation process had moved in such a way that Aliyev now has to raise the issue of the recognition of the independence of NKR among Azerbaijani society and at the same time in this way he tries to awake discontent of the society and use it to show that the recognition is "impossible".

Vigen Sargsyan Is Appointed RA Minister Of Defence: What To Expect?

Vigen Sargsyan will preserve and will develop current foreign political vector of the RA Defense Ministry. At the same time the reforms in the army and in the Ministry will even contribute to the raised effectiveness of the system, which, in its turn, among other will also positively affect our relations with our partners.

UK's Divorce from the EU can be "Painful"

If the sides are able to overcome internal crisis and at the same time build healthy cooperation, this "divorce" can even create new opportunities for them.

A Format for Further Talks on Karabakh Issue was Fixed in St. Petersburg

This format also has serious shortcomings, and the main one is the absence of NKR. Without NKR no real progress can be reached and that’s why the Co-Chairs of the OSCE MG always visit NKR and discuss the process with the government of Artsakh.

What Will the Resolution of Bundestag on Armenian Genocide Change?

At the same time, the recognition of this resolution can also bring forth some threats. It is not excluded that by the instigation of Turkey or by its own initiative Azerbaijan will try to resort to new provocations on the border with Armenia and NKR.

Humanitarian Summit in "Inhuman" Turkey

It is enough to remember that Turkey, under the pretext of fighting against terrorism, is warring against the Kurds that are its citizens, is massacring the peaceful Kurdish population and supports the terrorist activities of the Islamic State.

Will It be Possible to Pass to the Political Settlement of Karabakh Conflict?

If the investigation mechanisms of the OSCE do not work and there are no guarantees of peace, it will be illogical to expect concessions and progress in the political settlement.

The Importance and the Problems of the Expected Sargsyan-Aliyev Meeting in Vienna

The next step in this direction should be to return NKR to the negotiation table.

What does Azerbaijan Try to Change?

In this way official Baku as if is trying to fix the situation after April war and nullify the agreements and negotiations that were before that, including their legal basis.

Monopolization of the Negotiation Process can Contain Dangers

The format of three Co-Chairs, which presents the three centers of power, was not chosen by chance. Thus, an attempt was made to ensure a balance of forces and to establish a mechanism of checks and balances.

Escalation of the Situation in the South Caucasus is Not in the Interests of Europe

Second, the escalation of the conflict in the South Caucasus will inevitably lead to the strengthening of Russian influence in the region. And this, of course, is not in the EU's interests.

The EU Yielded Everything for Nothing

In exchange of all these, the EU got some promises, written on the paper and having no guarantees. Turkey promised to stop the flows of migrants to the EU and receive "unwanted" migrants.

Russia Needs Stability in the South Caucasus

Moscow tries to play balanced game with Yerevan and Baku and ensure "neutrality" of Azerbaijan and possibly restraine reactions of Armenia.

The Results of Mogherini's Visit and Armenia's Expectations from the EU

Therefore, it was no coincidence that the EU High Representative hurried to visit the region and reiterated the willingness of the EU to develop close relations with each country, to create individual format and stressed that "the cooperation with European Union does not exclude cooperation with other international alliances."

Europe Sends Positive Impulses to Armenia

Despite of pessimistic spirits because of accession of Armenia into the EAEU, the EU continues sending positive impulses to Armenia, which refer to economic cooperation as well.

Aliyev's Accusations to the Co-Chairs are Another Demonstration of Their Cynicism

Azerbaijani side has many times blamed the MG Co-Chars for working ineffectively, but this kind of accusation was heard for the first time.

PACE Resolutions should Not Lead to Negative Sentiments Towrads Europe

PACE also does not represent the official position of its member states. It is deputies that are included in the Parliamentary Assembly, who have different views and different interests, thus vote according to their own approaches.

For EAEU 2015 was a Year of Understanding Its Problems, Rather than Solving Them

This year certain steps have already been taken in this direction, in particular, Armenia proposed to help in the negotiations between the EAEU-Iran using its centuries-old experience of cooperation with Iran.

Karabakh Conflict Negotiation Process.: Year Review

During the past year, to promote the negotiation process, the co-chairs again tried to put into circulation the idea of "constructive negotiations," which, however, was not used in the negotiation process that is now in deadlock.

The EU has Revised Its Neighborhood Policy: What are on the Basis of This Revision?

In parallel, the new strategy pays great attention to its neighboring countries neighbors, their cooperation and their impact on the region. The need for cooperation with Turkey is noted in particular, as well as the importance of cooperation with Russia in order to face the common challenges.